Thursday, October 11, 2012

OVERSIGHT IN CYBERCRIME ACT LIBEL DOUBTFUL


The wave of Senate bills seeking to remove jail time as a punishment for libel following the public fury over the Cybercrime Prevention Act led me to one big question:

How could have the senators OVERLOOKED the outrageous penalties for libel in the Act, like the 12-year imprisonment and Justice Sec. Leila de Lima’s power to block anyone’s access to an Internet site if she thinks the person is committing the crime, until it was signed into law?

Was it really simply a case of oversight? Or did something happen during the deliberations before the Act was signed into law?

We have VERY SHARP LEGAL MINDS in the Senate, including the Act’s principal author Sen. Edgardo Angara. Personally, I found it INCONCEIVABLE that they did not foresee the people’s objection to the libel provision, especially its penalties.

But now that the public outcry is UNDENIABLE, there’s a SCRAMBLE in the Senate to decriminalize libel. Not only in the Act itself but also in the Revised Penal Code.

Nine bills seeking to amend the Code to remove imprisonment as a penalty for libel have been filed by the senators.

Four of these, WITHIN JUST TWO DAYS of the resumption of Congress and authored by Majority Leader Vicente Sotto III, Loren Legarda, Pia Cayetano and Minority Leader Alan Peter Cayetano.

Angara himself now says libel must still be punished BUT NOT with imprisonment. Sotto eventually withdrew his bill. Even Senate President Juan Ponce Enrile said lawmakers and the public should join forces in “polishing the law for the general good.”

Bottom line, the senators had been aware all along of the importance of decriminalizing 
libel.  But curiously, they seemed to have forgotten this while deliberating on the Act.

Otherwise, the 12-year jail time penalty for libel would not have escaped their scrutiny.

We can never tell exactly what seemed to have clouded the vision of the senators who did not object to the inclusion of libel and its dictatorial punishments in the Act.

But something was WRONG, SOMEWHERE ALONG THE WAY!

One thing few can be sure of, people, had we not voiced out our outrage, this flood of bills to decriminalize libel WOULD HAVE NEVER HAPPENED.

If only for this, we should all keep a very close watch on our senators. 30



No comments:

Post a Comment